THE FILTERMASTER

Best Pond Filter 2017 – Buyer’s Guide

If you own or intend to create a pond or water feature as part of your landscaping, you need a pond filter.

A pond filter keeps the water clear and maintains the health of the pond or water feature and any fish or plants it contains.

This buyer’s guide explains how to determine the correct size and type of filter for your pond or water feature and suggests eight filters for you to consider.

Selecting the Best Pond Filter 2017

NameSizeRateDimensionsWeight 
TetraPond Bio-Active
(Editor’s Choice)
1500 gallons4500 GPH17 x 15.4 x 18 inches ; 10 pounds16.8 pounds Check Price
OASE BioSmart 50005000 gallons2700 GPH23 x 16.1 x 19.1 inches18.2 pounds Check Price
Best Choice Products 4000 Liter
(Editor’s Choice)
2500 gallons2600 GPH14 x 14 x 20 inches ; 16 pounds17.8 pounds Check Price
Jebao CF-10 Pressured850 to 1250 gallons1500 GPH12.1 x 17.1 x 12 inches11 pounds Check Price
Pond Boss FM002Pup to 500 gallons320 GPH7 x 12.4 x 6.2 inches4.2 pounds Check Price
TetraPond 26596
(Editor’s Choice)
500 and 4500 gallons500 to 4500 GPH19.9 x 15.9 x 20.8 inches ; 1 pounds3.1 pounds Check Price
TetraPond Filtration Fountain Kit50 - 250 gallons325 GPH15.8 x 12.3 x 5.6 inches ; 4 pounds5.7 pounds Check Price
TetraPond Submersible Flat Box500 gallons200 to 2000 GPH12.4 x 10.3 x 4.7 inches ; 2.4 pounds2.5 pounds Check Price

1. The TetraPond Bio-Active : Provides a Complete Filtration System

Water passes through biological filtration after UV clarification to remove the algae cells, bacteria, protozoa, and other microbes killed by exposure to the UV light.

Back flush cleaning process removes dirt and debris from bio-active filter while leaving beneficial bacteria in place.

ModelUVMax Pond SizeGPHInlet/OutletDimensions
BP1500N/A1500 gallons50001 1/4" - 1 1/2"16 1/2" x 17" x 17 1/2"
BP2500N/A2500 gallons50001 1/4" - 1 1/2"16 1/2" x 17" x 21 1/4"
BP4000N/A4000 gallons50001 1/4" - 1 1/2"16 1/2" x 17" x 23"
BP1500 w/UV9 watts1500 gallons50001 1/4" - 1 1/2"16 1/2" x 17" x 17 1/2"
BP2500 w/UV18 watts2500 gallons50001 1/4" - 1 1/2"16 1/2&" x 17" x 21 1/4"
BP4000 w/UV18 watts4000 gallons50001 1/4" - 1 1/2"16 1/2" x 17" x 23"
This pressurized external filter provides mechanical and biological filtration with a UV clarifier for ponds of up to 1,500 gallons.
Manufacturer’s suggestion adds to the work of pond maintenance, adds to the owner’s water bill, and suggests changes to the pond that may not fit the pond owner’s design for the pond


Pros
  • Bio-active filter with unique open profile provides unrestricted water flow through large surface area
  • Water passes through mechanical filtration to remove debris before UV clarification
  • Water passes through a tube during UV clarification, forcing it into close contact with the UV light
Cons
  • Owners complained that back flush system does not adequately clean the bio-active filter
  • The manufacturer recommended back flushing the filter weekly, back flushing long enough to remove 10 percent to 30 percent of the water and then refilling the pond every two weeks, and adding plants to the pond

2. The OASE BioSmart 5000 : For a Low to Moderate Fish Load – a Buyer Favorite

This external gravity filter with mechanical and biological filters works with ponds containing up to 5,000 gallons and a low to moderate fish load.

The filter includes a gauge that displays the water temperature in the pond and a button that pops up when they filter needs cleaning.

With the built-in cleaning system, you will not have to manually remove and unclog the bio-filter.
Specification 
Filter Foams2 blue filter foams, 1 red filter foam, 1 green filter foam
Inlet ConnectionIntake: 3/4 in., 1 in., 1 1/4 in., 1 1/2 in.
Max. Flow Rate2700 GPH
ModelsBioSmart Flow-Through Pond Filters
Outlet Connection 2 3/4 in.
Sludge Drain Connection2 in.
Effective Pond Size5000 gallons (max); 2500 gallons (with fish stock); 1250 gallons (with koi)
Dimensions22 x 22 x 16 in.
Limited Warranty3 Years



Pros
  • This filter allows a low to moderate fish load in ponds up to 5,000 gallons
  • A temperature gauge displays the water temperature in the pond
  • A pop up button lets you know when the filter needs cleaning
  • The built-in cleaning system eliminates the need to manually clean the bio-filter
  • Pond owners literally gush over this filter
Cons
  • Some owners judged the outflow valve to be too flimsy
  • These owners purchased their own replacements and recommended others do the same

3. The Choice Products 4000 Liter Pressure : Includes integrated UV clarification – For a Normal Fish Load

This external pressurized bio filter also includes an integrated UV Clarifier.

It has a 12,000 liter or 2,500 gallon capacity with a normal fish load.

 

Specification 
Integrated 13W UV Clarifier (included)
120V/60Hz
15’Eletric cord
4000L/H- 12000 L/H
Suitable for ponds with normal fish load 4000 L/H
Suitable for ponds with heavy fish load 12000 L/H
Product dimension: 20"(H)x14” X14”
Package Included 
1 × CPF-180 pressure filter with integrated uvc
1 × spiral stepped hose adapter 1 ½” transparent
2 × spiral stepped hose adapter 1 ½” black
1 × spiral stepped hose adapter 1 ½” threaded, black
4 × union nuts 1 ½”
1× glass seal cover
4× flat seal
1× manual instruction
A multi-directional valve allows you direct the back flush where you want it to go when you clean the filter.


Pros
  • The filter includes both bio-filtration and an integrated UV clarifier
  • The filter has a 12,000 liter or 2,500 gallon capacity and allows a normal fish load
  • Owners like and recommend this filter
Cons
  • Some owners complain that sludge drains from the filter while they attach the back flush hose
  • Two owners suggested their own work-around solutions

4. The Jebao CF-10 Pressured : Best All-Around Filtration for Smaller Ponds

This pressurized external filter provides filtration for ponds up to 1,500 gallons with plants only, up to 1,000 gallons for a goldfish pond with some plants, and up to 500 gallons for a pond with large fish, such as a koi pond.

The filter includes mechanical and bio-filters as well as a UV Clarifier.

The manufacturer surrounds the UV lamp with quartz glass because ordinary glass reduces the penetration of the UV light by 90 percent. The filter also keeps the water as close as possible to the UV lamp and slows the flow of the water as it passes through the clarifier to further enhance the penetration of the light.

This filter offers a well-designed purification system. The system features an indicator that lets you know when the filter needs cleaning.


Pros
  • The filter includes both bio-filtration and an integrated UV clarifier
  • The filter has a 12,000 liter or 2,500 gallon capacity and allows a normal fish load
  • An indicator on the filter lets you know when it needs cleaning
  • Owners like and recommend this filter
Cons
  • Some owners complain that sludge drains from the filter while they attach the back flush hose
  • Two owners suggested their own work-around solutions

5. The Pond Boss FM002P : Durable, Versatile, All-in-One Choice for Small Ponds

This energy efficient, eco-friendly submersible filter combines mechanical and biological filtration for ponds up to 500 gallons.

The mechanical filtration system consists of two pads, one to capture larger particles and one to capture smaller particles.

The sloping lid on the case keeps debris from accumulating on top of the pump and filter. This system reduces maintenance and increases the longevity of the pump. The kit includes a compatible fountain pump, a waterspray nozzle, and a diverter valve that allows you to create a number of different water displays.

DOCUMENTATION

The kit both filters and aerates the water in your small pond while also providing an attractive fountain. This easy to install kit gets your pond filtration system running quickly.


Pros
  • The kit includes a filter with mechanical and biological filtration, a fountain pump, a waterspray nozzle, and a diverter valve to allow for a variety of fountain types
  • With the sloped lid on the case and two pads to capture large and small particles, this system is designed to reduce maintenance and improve pump longevity
  • Owners like this energy efficient kit
Cons
  • Many owners comment that, while the pump continues to work, the kit is so light that it floats and is jostled around in the water
  • Many owners suggested putting rocks in the case to weigh the kit down

6. The TetraPond 26596 Waterfall : Easy-to-Install, 12″-Wide Waterfall for Small Ponds

This waterfall filter attaches to either a submersible or external pump to create a 12″ waterfall for ponds up to 1,000 gallons.

It provides both mechanical and biological filtration although the biological filtration media is not included with the pump.

With this filter, you can choose between lava rock or bio-activators, which you must purchase separately. Lava rock has been the traditional choice, but bio-activators are popular.

Beneficial bacteria colonize either one, turning toxic nitrites into nitrates that nourish pond plants, improving your pond’s nitrogen cycle. Waterfalls provide not only an attractive look and sound but also increase the aeration of the water. To create this waterfall, your pump needs a flow rate between 500 gallons per minute and 4,500 gallons per minute.

The filter installs easily and blends into your pond’s landscape with the addition of a few rocks and decorations.


Pros
  • This waterfall filter includes both mechanical and biological filtration
  • The waterfall created by the filter improves water aeration in your pond
  • Uses either lava rock or bio-activators for biological filtration
Cons
  • Biological filtration media does not come with the pump. It must be purchased separately
  • A number of owners complain about problems connecting standard size tubing to the filter
  • For ease of installation and to prevent leaking, the correct size tubing must be purchased from the manufacturer

7. The TetraPond Filtration Fountain Kit : Add a Fountain to a Container Pond

This kit contains a submersible pump, coarse and fine pads for mechanical filtration, a fountain assembly with three heads to create three different fountain shapes, a diverter valve, and a swivel adjuster that levels the fountain heads. A knob controls the fountain’s width.

The pump provides a flow rate of 325 gallons per hour at a maximum head height of one foot.

That flow rate offers sufficient filtration for ponds up to 250 gallons. You can choose a bell-shaped fountain, a frothy fountain, or a spray fountain that hummingbirds might find particularly attractive. Fountains also add additional aeration to your pond’s water.

 FK5FK6
APPLICATIONSubmersibleSubmersible
POND SIZE50 - 250 Gallons200 - 500 Gallons
DIMENSIONS (FILTER BOX)11.5" L x 9.5" W x 5" H11.5" L x 9.5" W x 5" H
NUMBER OF FILTER PADS22
DIMENSIONS (FILTER PADS)9.5 W" x 12.2 L" x 2.4 H"9.5 W" x 12.2 L" x 2.4 H"
PUMP FLOW RATE325 GPH550 GPH
POWER CORD LENGTH12'12'
TUBING INCLUDED1' of 1" Kink-Free1' of 1" Kink-Free
WARRANTY3 Years3 Years

DOCUMENTATION

Owners of this fountain pond filter have found creative uses for it, including whiskey barrel ponds, planter ponds, and turtle ponds using a kiddie pool as a base.


Pros
  • This kit includes all that’s needed to add filtration and a fountain to a small pond
  • Three fountain heads offer a choice of a frothy fountain, a spray fountain, and a bell-shaped fountain
  • Creative owners use this fountain filter to create a variety of container ponds
Cons
  • The filter box tends to float, but that can be remedied by ensuring that the box fills completely with water or by weighing it down with rocks
  • A number of owners complained that parts cracked or that the pump stopped working

8. The TetraPond Submersible Flat Box Filter : Fits a wide variety of pumps 200 to 2000 gph

This submersible filter provides mechanical filtration of coarse and fine particles for ponds containing up to 500 gallons.

Owners report that the filter box has sufficient room to add bio-filters.

Fittings for various pumps come with the filter.

The filter works with pumps with flow rates between 200 gallons per hour and 2,000 gallons per hour. The filter easily detaches from the tubing for removal from the pond for cleaning.

Specifications 
Tubing: 12"L x 1"ID
1" MPT x 1" filter-to-hose barb fitting
Tubing fitting (3/4" MPT x 1" barb, 1" MPT x 1" barb, and 1-1/4" MPT x 1" barb)
Filter Box Dimensions - (12"L x 10"W x 4.25"H)
For ponds 250-500 gallons
1 year limited warranty
The manufacturer recommends holding the filter underwater until the case fills completely with water to prevent the filter from floating.


Pros
  • The filter includes fittings for various types of pumps
  • This filter combines with pumps producing flow rates of 200 gallons per hour to 2,000 gallons per hour to cleanse the water in ponds of up to 500 gallons
  • An owner reports that the filter case has room to add biological filtration
Cons
  • Because this filter only offers mechanical filtration, several owners combine it with an additional biological or ultraviolet filter
  • One owner reports that the filter does not disconnect easily from the tubing
  • Some owners needed to place rocks on top of the filter to keep it from floating

Best Pond Filter – Buyer’s Guide

When you buy a pond filter, there are three things you need to know to choose the best filter for your pond, water feature, or pond and water feature:

The amount of water and the number of fish determine the size filter you need. The type of filter you choose depends on whether you prefer to hide the filter within the pond or have it on land, and whether you prefer to have the water enter the filter before or after it passes through the pump. Your choice of a filter will also depend on whether or not you have a waterfall or fountain cascading into your pond.

Determining the Correct Size

Your pond pump and filter must run 24 hours a day. Consequently, at one time, a pump that filtered water once every two hours was acceptable. Since that time, however, pumps have become more energy efficient, reducing energy costs. Now, the new standard recommends a pump and filter that circulates water once every hour. Filtering the water once every hour results in healthier pond environments for you, your family and guests, and your fish and pond plants.

For Ponds With No Water Features or Fish

To determine the amount of water contained by a square or rectangular pool that is all one depth and that contains no water features or fish, you simply use this simple formula:

Length x Width X Depth X 7.5 = Gallons of Water

For a round or oval pond that is all one depth and contains no water features or fish, measure the diameter of the pond, divide the diameter by two to find the radius of the pond, and then use this formula:

3.14 x Radius x Radius x Depth x 7.5 = Gallons of Water

For a pond that contains no water features or fish but that has two or more depths, measure the depth of the pond at different levels. To find the average depth of the pond, add the measurements together, and divide by the number of times you measured the depth of the pond. Use the average depth to determine the gallons of water contained in your pond.

For a pond with an irregular shape with no water features or fish, find the average width by measuring the width of the pond at various points, add the measurements together, divide the measurements by the number of times you measured the pond’s width. Use the average width to find the gallons of water contained in your pond.

If your pond has multiple depths and an irregular shape but has no water features or fish, use the above methods to find the average depth and average width and use those figures to determine the gallons of water contained in your pond.

If your pond measures 5′ x 5′ x 1.5′ then it holds 281.25 gallons of water. You need a pump and filter that will circulate 281.25 gallons of water per hour. The pump should have a chart that lists how many gallons of water it circulates per hour.

For a Pond With a Water Feature

If you have a waterfall or fountain, you need to know how many feet of tubing you have between the pump and the waterfall or fountain; the number of 90° bends, ball valves, gate valves, and other adapters, reducers, and special fittings used with the tubing; how high your waterfall is; and how wide your waterfall is. You need this information to calculate the flow rate of your water feature and the total dynamic head pressure — the amount of pressure the pump needs to overcome in order to deliver the required flow rate for the water to the top, or “head height”, of your waterfall or fountain.

The width of your fountain or waterfall determines the flow rate. Your waterfall or fountain pump should move 125 gallons of water per hour for each inch of width for an average waterfall or fountain. For a gentler flow, use 100 gallons of water per hour or less for each inch of width. For the look of rapids, use 150 gallons of water per hour or more for each inch of width. To calculate the flow rate, use this formula:

Inches of Width X Gallons of Water Moved Per Hour = Flow Rate

Estimate the total dynamic head pressure with this formula:

H = Height (in feet) from the top of the water level in the pond to the top of the waterfall or fountain.
T = Total distance of tubing (in feet) from the pump to the waterfall or fountain.
A = Number of 90° angle bends and reducers used with the tubing.
B = Number of ball valves, bulkheads, and other miscellaneous adapters used with the tubing.

H + (T/10) + (A/2) + (B/4) = Estimated Head Pressure

So, for example, if you have a waterfall with a width, or headway, of 15″ and a height of 18″, and you want the sound of a gentle, soothing flow of water, you would want a pump capable of moving 1,500 gallons of water per hour at a height of 18″ against the estimated head pressure you have calculated.

Most pumps will have a chart that lists the flow rate the pump achieves at different heights. To estimate how the pump will perform at your estimated head pressure, start with the height of your waterfall or fountain and add an additional one foot of height for each 10′ of tubing between the pump and the waterfall or fountain.

For example, if you have a waterfall that is 18″ wide and 24″ high with 20′ of tubing between the pump and the waterfall and you want an average flow, you need a pump that produces a flow rate of 2,250 gallons per hour (GPH) at a height of 4′.

A pump that can power a water feature also possesses enough power to circulate the water in your pond frequently enough to keep the pond clean and healthy. However, pumps for water features can be too powerful for the pond filter. If that’s the case, you will need to install one pump for the water feature and one for the pond filtration system. Use one of the formulas above for calculating the amount of water contained in your pond, and purchase a pump capable of circulating that amount of water each hour.

For Ponds That Contain Fish

In addition to information about flow rates at various heights, the filtration system also will tell you its fish load. The fish load is the number and size of fish for which the pump can adequately supply clean water.

There is no generally accepted formula for calculating the size filtration system you need to support a particular number of fish. However, staying at or below five inches of fish per five gallons of water is regarded as an acceptable range.

If you have fewer than 100 small, two-inch long fish per 1,000 gallons of water, you aren’t likely to need to increase the size of your filtration system beyond what you need to circulate the water in your pond.

Keep in mind, though, that the fish in your pond will grow and multiply.

If, for example, you find you have 150 small fish per 1,000 gallons of water, you would need to increase the capacity of your filtration system by 1.5 percent. If you use your pond mainly as a fish pond, you will need a higher rate of filtration. If you have a pond that features fewer fish along with some plants, a system that adequately circulates the water in your pond is sufficient.

Fine Tuning Your Calculations

Certain factors, such as certain climates or locating a pond in full sun, cause your filtration system to work harder. Since it must run 24 hour a day, compensating for those factors reduces wear and tear and maintenance and replacement costs. To compensate for these factors, use the adjustments below:

If more than one of these factors applies to your pond, then take the answer from your first calculation to complete your next calculation. Then, take that answer to make the next calculation and so on until you have accounted for all of the factors that apply to your pond.

Finally, again to ease strain on your system, it is wise to purchase a filtration system with slightly more capacity than you need, so, multiply the figure you obtained after fine tuning by 1.5. Use that figure to represent the gallons of water your system will need to circulate per hour. If the figure falls between two filter sizes, purchase the larger one.

Types of Pond Filters

As you have seen from the product descriptions above, there are three types of pond filters — submersible pond filters, external pond filters, and pond skimmers and waterfall filters. These filters may use mechanical or biological filtration and an ultraviolet clarifier (UV-C).

In a mechanical filtration system, the water passes through a physical barrier, such as a foam block, which removes dirt and debris.

A biological filtration system, contains media that allows beneficial bacteria to grow and multiply. The bacteria convert harmful toxins like ammonia and nitrites from fish waste and decaying debris into nitrates which pond plants use as food. For this type of filtration to work, you need to maintain a balance between the bacteria and the waste products in the pond. To keep up as your fish grow and multiply, you will need to add more chambers for media or additional filters. Beneficial bacteria also colonize any rocks you add to your pond.

Ultraviolet clarification uses an ultraviolet light to kill algae cells, protozoa, harmful bacteria, and parasites. In order for the UV-C system to work, the ultraviolet light must penetrate the cell wall. The water must remain within the light long enough for that penetration to occur, so the pump cannot be so powerful that it moves the water too quickly through the filter. Newer systems swirl the water near the lamp to create more passes at a closer proximity. In addition, the longer the UV lamp, the greater the exposure that occurs. UV-C systems with 15 to 50 watt lamps will work with pumps with flow rates of 500 to 1,500 GPH. If you have purchased a separate UV clarifier and you have a pump with a higher capacity, install a “Tee” to reduce the load on the clarifier. The “Tee” allows some of the water to by pass the clarifier. If you do have a separate clarifier, the clarifier should be placed after the filter because dirt and debris in the water blocks the light. Because they operate 24 hours a day, the effectiveness of the ultraviolet light decreases over time. The bulb should be replaced once each year.

Submersible Pond Filters

Submersible pond filters sit inside the pond, which makes them the easiest type of filter to hide. They connect to the pump’s intake side, filtering the water of debris before it enters the pump and creates a clog. These filters work well for a pre-formed pond, a smaller pond containing an EDPM pond liner, or a formal pond that offers no place to hide an external filter. Submersible filters may offer mechanical filtration, biological filtration, or both. You can purchase the filters individually or as part of a kit that includes a pump and which may include other accessories, such as a fountain head or a diverter valve that sends water off to flow through a water feature. However, submersible filters must be removed from the pond for cleaning. If the filter is not removed carefully enough, some of the waste it has trapped could flow back into the pond.

External Pond Filters

External pond filters sit outside of the pond, which might be one reason they last longer than submersible pumps. They can be hidden with fake rocks. Because these filters do not take up space within the pond, they are larger than submersible filters, which makes them a good choice for larger ponds. Also, because they are larger, they can contain several types of media to cleanse the water. However, the water enters the filter from the pump, so the pump is vulnerable to clogs from floating debris. For that reason, it is a good idea to install a pre-filter on the intake side of the pump. External filters require the least cleaning, and they are the easiest to clean. Some newer, “self-cleaning” models have pressure chambers that compress as you turn a knob on the filter. The compression squeezes the water out of the media and flushes the collected debris out of the filter.

You can choose between two types of external pond filters — gravity pond filters and pressure or pressurized pond filters.

A gravity filter receives the water from the pump, but then the water trickles from the top to the bottom of the filter under the influence of gravity. The water must also flow back down into the pond under the influence of gravity. Consequently, gravity filters must sit on the ground above the height of the pond.

You can place a pressurized filter any distance from the pond. However, the farther the filter is from the pond, the more powerful your pump will have to be to push the water to the filter. Remember, every 10′ of tubing adds one foot of height to your calculation of the estimated head pressure the pump must achieve. Because these filters are pressurized, the water that passes through them does not have to flow downward into the pond. It can be directed up into a waterfall. Because they can be placed anywhere outside of the pond, pressurized pond filter are easy to access for cleaning and maintenance. For all of these reasons, pressurized filters have become a popular choice. They are the most common type of pond filter.

Pond Skimmers and Waterfall Filters

Pond skimmers act as pre-filters for your pond’s filtration system. They remove 80 percent to 90 percent of the leaves and other debris floating on your pond’s surface. Pond skimmers usually are buried beside the pond and attached to the pond liner. While they can be added to an existing pond, it requires more work than including a skimmer when the pond is created. Pond skimmers can house an external pond filter, providing a place to hide it and eliminating the need for a submersible pump hidden in the pond. Pond skimmers are sufficient to serve as the entire filtration system for some ponds. They can be used in large ponds, small ponds, and preformed ponds. You can reduce pond maintenance by a adding bottom drains, a UV Clarifier, or an auto-fill valve to your pond skimmer.

You can add a waterfall filter to your pond anytime you decide to add a waterfall. The water enters the filter from the pump and flows through the mechanical and biological filters. These filters then send the water out through a lip, or weir, that creates a 1′ to 4′ wide stream that can fall in an unbroken sheet into the pond or be channeled over rocks to form a cascade.

Voltage and Energy Consumption

If you don’t have access to your electrical supply in the area where you want to locate your pond, in the United States, you will need to have an electrician install a 110V or 230V GFCI (Ground Fault Circuit Interrupter) outlet. As has been mentioned previously, your pond’s filtration system must run continuously to keep the water clean and the pond healthy. For that reason, you should choose a pump that uses the lowest wattage possible to save on energy consumption and reduce your electric bill. According to Mark Charles Moser, COO and Head Technician of AZPonds.com, external pumps use less energy than submersible pumps, particularly in the 3,000 GPH to 6,000 GPH range. Moser states that an external pump with a 6,000 GPH capacity should run well at only 450 watts while a submersible pump with the same capacity would require 750 watts to 1,200 watts. Taking energy consumption into consideration when choosing your pond filtration system could save you several hundred dollars per year.

This buyer’s guide should supply all the information you need to find the combination of pump and filter that will keep your pond water healthy and clear and your water features operating beautifully.